Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Oct 20, 201610:17 AM
Haute Plates

Our weekly blog on the New Orleans fine dining scene

Trip Advisor Gets It Right, Sort Of

GW Fins


            I love GW Fin’s. It is one of the best restaurants in New Orleans, which to my mind means it is one of the best restaurants in the world. Tenney Flynn is a genius chef, and a great guy. When I celebrate a special occasion, more often than not, it’s at GW Fin’s. I asked my wife to marry me at GW Fin’s, and the poor thing said “yes,” so I have a soft spot, obviously.

            I am also fond of the Upperline. It’s one of the first fine-dining restaurants at which I ate as an adult, and I’ve been back many times in the years since. There is no more gracious host than JoAnn Clevenger; it’s simply not possible.

            That said, the recent news that Trip Advisor rated GW Fin’s and the Upperline the 18th and 19th best restaurants in the country struck me as a bit odd.


            But … that list had four restaurants in Charleston in the top 25. Four.

            In Charleston.

            Charleston is a great town, and there’s a fantastic restaurant scene there, but four of the best 25 restaurants in the country are in Charleston? No.

            I am pleased that GW Fin’s and the Upperline have gotten well-deserved recognition, though I suppose it will be even more difficult to get a reservation at either in the near future. Both restaurants are fantastic, as are, I’m sure, all of the restaurants from Charleston named by Trip Advisor.

            But why are we, or Charleston for that matter, supposed to be in competition with places like New York, Chicago, Los Angeles or, dare I say it, Houston for the “best restaurant” sweepstakes? New Orleans is New Orleans. New Orleans is not New York; and New York is not New Orleans.       

            We cannot compete with cities like New York for “best restaurant,” because to be blunt, we don’t have the numbers. You can have the best meal of your life in New Orleans, whether it’s at a white tablecloth restaurant or a hole in the wall; that’s true even if you’ve experienced Michelin-starred restaurants all over the world. Our food culture is second to none, but …

            We aren’t the sort of place that can support restaurants like Alinea, the French Laundry, Le Bernardin, Eleven Madison Park, and a host of other places where you’ll pay upwards of $500 for a meal paired with wines that will blow you away. We don’t need to be that sort of place; we’re better than that sort of place, on balance, because while we don’t have the apex restaurants you’ll find in New York, Chicago and Los Angeles, our “casual” joints are, pound for pound, as good as or better than the best those other places have to offer.

            And what I love about GW Fin’s and the Upperline is that both of those places represent our food culture in an elevated, ambitious way. So while I had one of the meals of my life at Alinea, and have enjoyed dining in New York, Chicago, Paris, San Francisco, London, Boston, Rome and elsewhere, at the end of the day I’d rather eat at GW Fin’s, the Upperline, or dozens of other New Orleans restaurants.



Add your comment:
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Haute Plates

Our weekly blog on the New Orleans fine dining scene


Robert D. Peyton was born at Ochsner Hospital and, apart from four years in Tennessee for college and three years in Baton Rouge for law school, has lived in New Orleans his entire life. He is a strong believer in the importance of food to our local culture and in the importance of our local food culture, generally. He has practiced law since 1994, and began writing about food on his website, www.appetites.us, in 1999. He mainly wrote about partying that year, obviously.

In 2006, New Orleans Magazine named Appetites the best food blog in New Orleans. The choice was made relatively easy due to the fact that Appetites was, at the time, the only food blog in New Orleans.

He began writing the Restaurant Insider column for New Orleans Magazine in 2007 and has been published in St. Charles Avenue, Louisiana Life and New Orleans Homes and Lifestyles magazines. He is the only person he knows personally who has been interviewed in GQ magazine, albeit for calling Alan Richman a nasty name. He is not proud of that, incidentally. (Yes, he is.)

Robert’s maternal grandmother is responsible for his love of good food, and he has never since had fried chicken or homemade biscuits as good as hers. He developed his curiosity about restaurant cooking in part from the venerable PBS cooking show "Great Chefs" and has an extensive collection of cookbooks, many of which do not require coloring, and some of which have not been defaced.

Robert lives in Mid-City with his wife Eve and their three children, and is fond of receiving comments and emails. Please humor him.




Atom Feed Subscribe to the Haute Plates Feed »

Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags