Speaking Out

Parade Quality: Taking a stand in Jefferson

AN ORIGINAL ©MIKE LUCKOVICH CARTOON FOR NEW ORLEANS MAGAZINE

On matters of Carnival parades, we’re strict Darwinists: No parade has an inherent right to survive; only the fittest should make it to the streets.

In that spirit, we applaud an ordinance implemented by the Jefferson Parish council, which, over a series of years, will enforce more demands on parading krewes. The ordinance, initiated by council member Cynthia Lee-Sheng, will require more marching bands, regulate recorded music and mandate that float riders be masked and costumed. Similar laws have already been in place in Orleans Parish. Jefferson has tried to deal with such deficiencies before, but the rules were generally loosened, especially in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina.

Parade quality is something that should be taken seriously. The marches use public streets and public services and strain area neighborhoods and businesses. We don’t buy the arguments that the parades are an economic development tool. In Jefferson, the parades draw mostly locals rather than attract tourists. We don’t think that economic impact should be the total justification for parades, nor do we believe that shabby parades should be allowed to have a negative impact. We would hope that no one’s first experience at seeing a Mardi Gras parade is to witness a bad one and think that that represents the whole.

At their best, Carnival parades are the products of groups that put a lot of thought, effort and money into their presentation. At their worst, some parade groups aren’t really krewes but entrepreneurial ventures of promoters who lease second-hand floats, hire a few bands and sell ridership. That isn’t what Carnival should be. Carnival, and Jefferson Parish, would be better off with a few high-quality parades rather than many mediocre ones.

Speaking of which, we urge that those who want to be in involved with Carnival should look beyond the traditional parade as an outlet. In Orleans Parish, for example, in recent years there has been an explosion of street-level marching clubs that have added a whole new level of humor and creativity to the season. In Jefferson, while we don’t like the term “Family Gras” (It translates to “Fat Family”) we do like the nature of the event, which brings live music and entertainment to the Veterans Boulevard median. There should be more of that. Music and dancing should always be as much a part of Carnival as float riding and bead catching.

Congratulations, Jefferson Parish, for taking a bold and needed step. Keep your Carnival strong. Like a benevolent monarch, you could set an example for the entire region.

You Might Also Like

10 Things To Do in New Orleans This Weekend

Our top picks for events this weekend.

10 Things to Do In New Orleans This Weekend

Our top picks for things to do in New Orleans this weekend.

10 Things To Do in New Orleans This Weekend

Our top picks for this weekend's events.

Quenching Your Inner Beach Thirst

Have a taste of the beach wherever you are with these 4 cocktail recipes.

10 Things To Do in New Orleans This Weekend

Our top picks for this weekend's events.

Reader Comments:
Feb 11, 2012 07:42 pm
 Posted by  The Epicure

"On matters of Carnival parades, we’re strict Darwinists: No parade has an inherent right to survive; only the fittest should make it to the streets."

While I share many of your sentiments, you are NOT strict Darwinists. A Darwinist would embrace "survival of the fittest" -- presuming that krewes that do not appeal to members and to the viewing public would wither and die, as members don't join, and as the public doesn't come out to view. If people want marching bands, they'll watch the parades with marching bands and eschew those without.

This Government mandate is the opposite. It is NOT Darwinism. It is "Intelligent Design" -- some superior entity deciding what a krewe should be -- or not.

The reason that krewes have changed over the past 150 years is because of evolution -- not by "creationism" by busybody Government meddlers. Had there been a politburo run by Ms. Cynthia Lee-Sheng a hundred years ago that codified what a parade should -- and should not -- have, there would have been no marching bands allowed.

Certainly the desire to "improve" is laudable.

But don't go around calling this Darwinism -- it is the opposite of that.

Add your comment:

Latest Posts

Dreams of Sushi

Learning about the Japanese food from the experts

10 Things To Do in New Orleans This Weekend

Our top picks for events this weekend.

On the Move

With the right tools, even moving day can be infused with little luxuries.

Five Cheap Red Wines

Some grapes and the wines they make are available at lower prices than you might have imagined.

Checking in on New Year's Resolutions

Trying to stick to fun New Year's resolutions